Audit report, part 4: unapproved pesticides on farm produce, late drains and waste piling up
Part 4 of 4 of our reading of the Director of Audit's 2024-25 report: food, waste, drains, the police, the courts and what the state paid after court cases.
Photo: GregRoquette, CC BY-SA 4.0
In short
Part 4 of 4: Part 1 covered the debt, part 2 housing and water, part 3 health, social aid and schools.(1) This last part covers food, waste, drains, the police and the courts.(1)
Your vegetables and fruit: from January to August 2025, 17.2% of the vegetable and fruit samples tested had a pesticide not approved for that crop, and 5.7% had more residue than the legal limit.(1) No fine was imposed.(1)
Floods: the state's drains company had finished 5 of its 63 projects.(1) The Ministry of Finance did not approve 10 contracts worth Rs 2.1 billion, 7 of them in high-risk flood zones.(1)
Waste: at the La Chaumière transfer station, waste piled up to 12,845 tonnes, where the limit is 500 tonnes.(1)
Court cases: the state paid Rs 90.6 million in compensation in 2024-25, up from Rs 13.9 million in 2020-21, including Rs 17 million for medical errors.(1)
This is part 4 of 4
Every year the Director of Audit, the official who checks how the government spent public money, publishes a report. The one on 2024-25 runs to 986 pages.(1) Part 1 (3 November) covered the public finances, part 2 (5 November) social housing, water pipes and dams, the Triolet sports complex and police equipment, and part 3 (6 November) health, social aid and schools.
This last part follows the money into everyday safety: the food on your plate, the drains that carry rainwater, the waste and beaches around you, the police and prisons, and the courts. It ends with the compensation the state pays, mostly after court judgments against it. At the end we say what the four parts leave out.
Pesticides on vegetables and fruit
Start with food. Pesticides are chemicals sprayed on crops to protect them from insects and disease. The Use of Pesticides Act 2018 controls them and set up the Pesticides Regulatory Office, inside the Ministry of Agro-Industry, to enforce it.(1) The law asks two things of farmers. A crop may be sprayed only with the pesticides listed for that crop, and the traces left on the harvest, called residues, must stay below a legal limit, the Maximum Residue Level.(1)
To check, officers of the Office take samples of vegetables and fruit from farms, markets, auction markets and supermarkets and send them to the Food Technology Laboratory for testing.(1) The results for January to August 2025 are worse than for 2024. Of 714 samples, 41, or 5.7%, had more residue than the legal limit.(1) And 17.2% carried a pesticide not recommended for that crop, meaning not on the approved list for it, up from 10.6% in 2024.(1) The report does not say that anyone was made ill. Its concern is that the rules are not being enforced.(1)
The gap is in what happens after a failed test. A planter whose sample fails receives an improvement notice, which gives 14 days to put things right, and the planters were aware that even with a non-recommended pesticide they would receive only that.(1) From 2024 to August 2025, 308 samples failed, and 191 improvement notices were sent to planters.(1) In most cases nobody followed up after the 14 days, and no fines were imposed, even for repeat offences.(1) The auditor says this lacks the deterrence needed to prevent abuse.(1) The Office's officers were also not trained enough to prosecute planters, the National Audit Office was told.(1)
The testing itself is stretched too. The laboratory has three machines that test for residues. In October 2025 two were out of order, and the third, the only one in use, had had no maintenance since February 2025, so it could not run at full capacity.(1) The Government Analyst Division, the Health Ministry's own chemistry laboratory, cannot test for pesticides such as glyphosate and paraquat either, as part 3 showed.(1) Imported produce is a further gap. The law requires every importer to give the Office a certificate from a competent authority stating the residue level, but the certificate was not requested from suppliers.(1)
Drains, roads and floods
Food is one risk that arrives at home. Water is another. Over the past 15 years Mauritius has had flash floods, sudden floods after intense rainfall, that caused deaths and widespread damage, among them the deadly Port Louis flood of 2013 and Cyclone Belal in January 2024.(1)
The state's answer is the National Flood Management Programme, launched in the 2021-22 Budget with Rs 11.7 billion to build about 1,700 drain projects in 3 years in high-risk zones.(1) Two bodies carry out parts of it. The National Development Unit, which builds community infrastructure, was given 988 of the projects. Drains Infrastructure Construction Ltd, the state-owned company set up in November 2021 to speed up the high-risk areas, was given 63.(1)
By 30 June 2025 the Unit had completed 187 of its 988 projects, 19%, and 347 were still at design stage.(1) It had spent Rs 2.9 billion of the Rs 7.4 billion budgeted.(1) The state's drains company had finished 5 of its 63 projects.(1)
Why so slow? The report says the causes are the same as in earlier years: poor contractor performance, bidding problems, difficulty acquiring land, design delays, moving underground pipes and cables, and cost and time overruns.(1)
Then there are the projects that stopped. In June 2025 the Ministry of Finance did not approve the award of 10 drain contracts worth Rs 2.1 billion, 7 of them in high-risk flood zones, after Rs 22 million had been spent at the design stage on consultants and land.(1) The National Development Unit says the designs are approved and the drains will be built once funds are available.(1) The report notes that cancelling projects increased the risk of flooding in rainy seasons.(1)
Port Louis shows what is at stake. It is a high-risk flood zone, and after Cyclone Belal in January 2024 cars were submerged and roads could not be used.(1) Yet of the 11 projects identified there as high-risk since 2021-22, 6 were still at design stage on 30 June 2025.(1)
Planning problems show up on roads too. The Ministry of Finance refused clearance for the next stage of 4 road projects, so they were put on hold after about Rs 1.5 billion had been spent on consultancy, the fees paid to consultants for studies and designs. Rs 990 million of it went on the new link road from Britannia to Rivière des Anguilles.(1) The auditor says this points to poor project planning.(1)
Waste and beaches
Drains carry rainwater away. Waste is the other thing a country must carry away every day. The Solid Waste Management Division of the Ministry of Environment runs 5 transfer stations, where waste is gathered before being trucked to the Mare Chicose landfill, the site where it is buried.(1)
At La Chaumière, one of the stations, the contract says the 500 tonnes of waste arriving each day must all go on to the landfill.(1) From January 2024 to March 2025 that did not happen: on several occasions the waste waiting there exceeded 500 tonnes, reaching as much as 12,845 tonnes.(1) The operator was charged penalties of Rs 13.2 million, and the state hired relief contractors to cart away about 7,000 tonnes from La Chaumière and the same again from La Brasserie station.(1) By September 2025 the Division had not yet claimed back Rs 21 million from the service provider for that work.(1) The report does not describe any harm to residents from the pile-up.
The landfill itself is being raised. In June 2024 the Division awarded a contract of about Rs 4.2 billion for a vertical expansion of the Mare Chicose landfill, meaning making it higher, and for running it, from 1 July 2024.(1) A year later, in June 2025, construction of the plant meant to use the gas the landfill gives off had not started.(1)
The plan to send less to the landfill is late too. Two integrated waste processing plants, which would sort, compost and recycle household waste, are due to run by March 2027.(1) In October 2025 the land for them had still not been secured.(1)
Waste is also a beach problem. Mauritius has 145 proclaimed public beaches, meaning officially declared ones, and 93 of them are cleaned by private contractors, supervised by 9 beach enforcement officers and 2 senior ones.(1) The Beach Authority, the public body that looks after beaches, had only about 16.5% of the 115 refuse collectors it needs to clean 52 beaches regularly.(1) At the 9 beaches the auditors visited in October 2025, there was no cleaning staff on site, the beach areas were uncleaned and waste had not been carted away.(1)
Plastic is the last strand. In 2020 Mauritius banned many single-use plastic products and plastic bags.(1) Rules making producers responsible for used drink containers, plastic bottles included, with a deposit refund scheme, drafted in 2021, were still not final in November 2025.(1) On 19 September 2025 the government decided not to extend the pause on the 2020 plastic bag rules, which had run to 31 August 2025, and approved new definitions of plastic, biodegradable and compostable bags instead.(1)
Police, prisons and courts
The police findings start with a cash shortfall. The Northern Division's cash office collected revenue, and for 2009 to 2013 the auditors found an unexplained difference of Rs 44.5 million between what the cash book recorded and what was banked.(1) Rs 12.7 million was recovered, leaving Rs 31.8 million.(1) One police officer was suspended from duty in April 2015 and has been paid Rs 3.2 million in salary and allowances since then.(1) More than 10 years on, the enquiry was still open in October 2025, and the case went to the Director of Public Prosecutions, the official in charge of prosecutions, in June 2025.(1) The report does not say that anyone has been found guilty.
Some police equipment has never been used. In 2014 the police bought a remotely operated vehicle, a bomb disposal robot, so that officers would not have to handle suspect packages by hand.(1) Rs 12.8 million was paid, but it has never been used, and in September 2025 it was lying idle.(1) The police say it was defective. The supplier denies a breach, and the dispute has been before an arbitrator, a neutral person appointed to settle it outside court, since June 2018 without a decision.(1) The auditor notes that in those 11 years the bomb disposal unit made 103 manual interventions that put officers' lives at risk.(1)
Old ammunition is another worry. The police central armoury keeps firearms and ammunition for the police.(1) About 131,000 rounds there are past their 10-year shelf life, and some have been stored there since 2001.(1) They came from two decommissioned Coast Guard patrol vessels and still belong to the Coast Guard, the police say.(1) Neither the police nor local agencies have the expertise to test whether they are safe. In November 2022 the Commissioner of Police sought approval to ask the Indian Navy for help, yet by November 2025 no inspection had been carried out.(1) The report says accidental explosions causing damage to property or life could happen if ammunition is not properly secured or destroyed.(1)
Everyday services lag too. A 2019 law, the Road Traffic (Amendment 3) Act, was passed to bring in digital driving licences and online payment of traffic fines, but by September 2025 it had still not been proclaimed, meaning formally brought into force.(1) Driving tests still cannot be booked online: appointments are made at the examination centres.(1) On 6 and 14 October 2025 the waits the auditors noted at the Line Barracks licensing office for practical test appointments and international driving licences ran from 31 minutes to 1 hour 19 minutes.(1) The police say the wait has since fallen.(1)
The next cost sits in the prisons. In August 2025 the Prison Service held 2,842 detainees, and 1,223 of them, 43%, were on remand, held while waiting for trial or sentence.(1) They have not been convicted by a court and may be released on bail.(1) The report puts the cost of keeping them at about Rs 444 million a year, 43% of the budgeted figure, and says savings of some Rs 440 million could be made if the issue were addressed.(1) It points to provisional charges, which the prosecution can change later, the financial barriers to bail and the court process.(1) The Prison Service replies that the decision to remand or release rests with the judiciary.(1)
Behind those numbers sit the courts. The Judiciary, the system of courts that hears civil and criminal cases, had 66,919 cases waiting at the end of December 2024, down from 71,854 a year earlier, because it closed 93,521 cases while 88,586 new ones came in.(1) Eighty per cent of the waiting cases, 53,239, were in the District Courts, the local courts.(1) The report says that at this pace it will take a long time to clear them, and that absent witnesses or parties and requests by lawyers are the main reasons cases are postponed.(1) The Judiciary replies that judges and magistrates have valid reasons to postpone cases.(1)
What the state paid after court cases
Courts also decide when the state itself must pay. Under the State Proceedings Act, a person who suffers harm or loss from what a government department or public official did, or failed to do, can claim compensation.(1) In 2024-25 the state paid Rs 90.6 million, up from Rs 13.9 million in 2020-21, an increase of 552%, mainly because of court judgments against it.(1)
The largest part, Rs 58.7 million, followed the ending of contracts.(1) The report details two cases. A salvage company was hired to remove oil from, re-float and scuttle a fishing vessel grounded near St Brandon. Bad weather left the work incomplete and the contract was terminated. After arbitration, the two sides settled for USD 850,000, paid as Rs 39.4 million, so in all the state paid more than the original contract value although the work done was limited.(1) The other is the Rs 19.3 million in damages for the cancelled first contract at the Triolet sports complex, which part 2 described.(1)
Medical negligence cost Rs 17 million, in 4 cases settled after errors in care.(1) The auditor calls them avoidable errors, notably surgical material left in the body and improper medical procedures.(1) One, settled for Rs 2.5 million, was a surgical pack left in a patient's abdomen after childbirth.(1)
Road accidents cost Rs 11.7 million, and two cases made up 88% of it.(1) The larger, Rs 9.2 million paid in September 2024, followed an accident in 2018 involving a police vehicle in which two pedestrians died at a crossing.(1) The families of the victims had taken legal action.(1)
Last, there is money the state has not paid and may never pay. At 30 June 2025, 295 cases against the state, worth Rs 76.6 billion, were still pending.(1) The accounts disclose this in a note as a contingent liability: money the state might have to pay, but only if it loses.(1) The auditor asks for a State Litigation Management Committee at the Attorney General's Office, the government's legal adviser, to monitor the cases and reduce their cost to public finances.(1)
What it means for you
So how does all this reach a family? Take one finding at a time, and keep to what the report says.
Vegetables and fruit. Picture your Saturday shop for vegetables and fruit. Of the 714 samples tested from January to August 2025, 123 carried a pesticide not approved for that crop, 17.2%, close to one in six (our rounding), and 41 carried more residue than the legal limit.(1) The report does not say that anyone was made ill. It says the checks are weak: a failed sample brings only a notice, residue certificates are not requested for imports, and the testing machines are out of order or not maintained.(1) As general food-safety advice, not from the report, washing and peeling can remove some residues on the surface, but not pesticide absorbed inside the plant.
Floods. Imagine heavy rain at night and a street in one of the zones the Land Drainage Authority calls high-risk. Whether the water drains away depends on drains that are not all built. In Port Louis, 6 of the 11 high-risk projects were still at design stage in June 2025, and the drains company had finished 5 of its 63.(1) The report itself says that cancelling projects increased the risk of flooding in rainy seasons.(1) It does not say when any given street will be done. If you live in a flood-prone area, ask your council or MP what is planned near you.
Waste and beaches. Every household's rubbish ends up somewhere. At one transfer station the waiting waste reached 12,845 tonnes, against the 500 tonnes a day the contract says must be moved on, and by September 2025 the Division had not yet claimed back from the operator Rs 21 million for carting away about 14,000 tonnes from La Chaumière and La Brasserie.(1) The report does not describe any harm to residents, so we cannot say more. On the beaches, the auditors found no cleaning staff at the 9 they visited in October 2025.(1) If you find a public beach left dirty, tell the Beach Authority, which the report says has only about 16.5% of the cleaners it needs for 52 beaches.(1)
Courts and compensation. If you are ever called to court as a witness or a party, turn up: in the Judiciary's figures, absent witnesses (33%) and absent parties (25.7%) are among the main reasons cases are postponed.(1) The state's compensation bill comes out of the same budget as your services: the Rs 90.6 million of 2024-25 is more than six times the Rs 13.9 million of 2020-21 (90.6 / 13.9 = 6.5, our calculation).(1) Avoidable errors in medical care cost twice: once for the patient, then again in court. And the 1,223 people held on remand cost about Rs 444 million a year, and the report says savings of some Rs 440 million could be made if that issue were addressed.(1)
What the four parts cover, and what they leave out
This was the last of the four parts, so the series is now complete. Part 1 (3 November) covered the public finances, part 2 (5 November) social housing, water pipes and dams, the Triolet sports complex and police equipment, part 3 (6 November) health, social aid and schools, and this part food, waste, drains, the police, prisons and the courts.(1)
The four parts do not cover the whole 986-page report. Its list of audit areas also includes, among others, the blue economy and fisheries, the move to renewable energy, tourism, labour, grants to bodies such as the National Women Council, the foreign affairs ministry's missions abroad, cybersecurity, the disciplinary process for suspended public officers, claims for extra time at the Ministry of Local Government, the fire station at Goodlands, police helicopters, ships and aircraft, farm seeds, animal quarantine and stray dogs, and the sections where the auditor follows up last year's recommendations or notes non-compliance with legislation.(1) The full report is public on the National Audit Office website.
