MoBriefsOpen in MoBriefs

Public finances · 6 November 2026 · 12 min

Audit report, part 3: emergencies without SAMU, untested medicines and tablets nobody uses

Part 3 of 4 of our reading of the Director of Audit's 2024-25 report: what the auditor found in health, social aid and schools.

Testing samples at the Central Health Laboratory in Candos, 2020

Photo: IAEA Imagebank, CC BY 2.0

In short

Part 3 of 4: Part 1 covered the debt and part 2 housing and water.(1) This part covers health, social aid and schools. Part 4 follows on 7 November.

Emergencies: in 2024 the SAMU handled 14,673 of 43,123 emergency interventions, about a third.(1) In July 2025, 523 emergencies that needed the SAMU after 4 pm went unattended, about 16 a day.(1)

Food and medicines: food inspections fell 47% in three years, and none of 107 medicines already on sale and listed for quality checks had been tested by September 2025.(1)

Schools: the tablet programme for primary schools cost Rs 1.45 billion, but in 2025 teachers in almost no school logged in to the system for Grades 5 and 6.(1)

Social aid: Rs 14.5 million of overpaid social aid was still unrecovered in June 2025.(1) Many new cases came from a new job or a marriage that was not reported in time.(1)

This is part 3 of 4

Every year the Director of Audit, the official who checks how the government spent public money, publishes a report. The one on 2024-25 runs to 986 pages.(1) Part 1 (3 November) looked at the public finances, and part 2 (5 November) at social housing, water, a sports complex and police equipment.

This part follows the money into services that most families use or rely on: the emergency ambulance, the checks on food and medicines, care for older people, payments to people on low incomes, and primary schools. Part 4, on 7 November, covers food, waste, drains, the police and the courts.

When you call an ambulance

Start with the emergency ambulance. Mauritius has two kinds. The SAMU is the emergency medical service: its vehicles carry emergency doctors and medical staff who can treat a patient on the spot.(1) Routine ambulances are mainly used for other jobs, such as taking patients home from hospital or to outpatient care, although they also step in when no SAMU vehicle is free.(1) The Ministry of Health has 11 SAMU vehicles and 59 routine ambulances.(1)

The auditor found that the SAMU reaches only a minority of emergencies. In 2024 there were 43,123 emergency interventions. The SAMU carried out 14,673 of them, about a third. The other 28,450 went by routine ambulance, police vehicle or the patient's own means, which the report says happens when the SAMU is unavailable or busy.(1) The risk, in the auditor's words, is that a patient in a vehicle without a medical team may not be properly stabilised and may reach hospital in a more critical condition.(1)

Why so few? Part of the answer is how many vehicles are on the road, and when. From 8 am to 4 pm the SAMU runs two vehicles for each of the 5 regional hospitals. From 4 pm to 8 am it runs only one per region.(1) The vehicles are also old and often out of action: most are between 7 and 15 years old, and on 22 September 2025 only 7 of the 11 were available, 63% against the 90% the World Health Organization recommends.(1) The auditor puts the root cause on planning: the Ministry never reviewed what the system needs, and it did not move vehicles to the hospitals with the most calls, A.G. Jeetoo and Victoria.(1)

The gaps show up in the figures. From October to December 2024, during the day shift, 888 interventions that needed the SAMU went without it because every vehicle was already busy.(1) The evening is worse. In July 2025, 2,198 emergencies needed the SAMU, and 523 of them, almost one in four, came after 4 pm and went unattended, because the region's only vehicle was already on another case. That is about 16 a day.(1) The Ministry has invited bids for 4 new SAMU vehicles.(1)

Food checks

Emergencies are what everyone sees. A quieter part of health is prevention, and it slipped too. Food inspections are visits by health officers to places that prepare or sell food, to check that they follow the rules. Those visits fell from 21,394 in 2021-22 to 11,331 in 2024-25, down 47%. Inspections of school canteens fell 43%, from 1,105 to 628.(1)

Over the same years, the number of gastroenteritis cases treated rose from 109,424 in 2021 to 275,813 in 2024, up 152%. Gastroenteritis is an infection of the stomach and gut, and the report counts it among the illnesses that come from food. The auditor notes that the fall in inspections and the rise in illness coincided, but does not say one caused the other.(1) The Ministry says its inspectors were sent to fight dengue and chikungunya.(1)

Laboratories and medicines

Inspectors check the premises. The laboratory checks the product. The Government Analyst Division is the Health Ministry's chemistry laboratory, which tests food and health products.(1) The auditor found its equipment and supplies falling short.

Take pesticides, the chemicals sprayed on crops. The laboratory tests for pesticide residues, the traces left on food. But a key part of one of its high-tech machines has been broken since May 2018, more than 7 years. The machine it uses instead cannot detect several pesticides on the Codex international pesticide list, including glyphosate and paraquat.(1) Other tests have stopped too: the colour test on drinking water since November 2024, with 84 samples waiting on 8 August 2025, and the test for carbon monoxide poisoning in blood since June 2022.(1)

Medicines face a similar gap. A medicine is checked before it is allowed on sale, but its quality is also meant to be checked afterwards, on what sits in pharmacies. The report calls this post-market surveillance. In January 2024 the Ministry's pharmacovigilance unit, the team that watches the safety of medicines once they are in use, sent the laboratory a list of 97 medicines to test, and in March 2024 it added 10 antibiotics.(1) By September 2025 none of the 107 had been tested. The tests include the weight and hardness of the tablet, how fast it breaks down, which active ingredient it contains and how much, and how well the body absorbs it. The laboratory lacked the reagents, the chemicals used in the tests, and the certified reference materials it compares samples against.(1) Testing of how well the body absorbs medicines has been stopped since April 2011, because a machine is broken.(1)

One thing must be clear. The report does not say that any of these medicines was faulty. It says nobody checked.

Care for older people

Mauritius is ageing. It had 251,795 people aged 60 or more in 2024, about one in five, and the report expects about 293,000, nearly 28% of the population, by 2044.(1) Geriatrics is the branch of medicine for older people, and the report finds the state has not built it up. In September 2025 only 3 geriatric specialists were registered. The only specialised service is dementia care, in clinics at the 5 regional hospitals. There are no dedicated clinics for falls, fragile health or osteoporosis, so older patients go through general outpatient departments.(1)

Plans have been dropped before. In 2010 the state bought the Medpoint clinic for Rs 144.7 million to turn it into a geriatric hospital. That hospital was never set up, and in 2020 the building became a cancer hospital. The auditor could not say why, because no project file exists.(1) A pilot of specialised wards at Jawaharlal Nehru Hospital stopped during Covid-19 and did not restart.(1)

Housing follows the same pattern. The state planned 2 homes, at Palmar and Flic-en-Flac, for low-income older people who live alone and pay rent of Rs 3,500 a month. Rs 50 million was set aside in 2017-18, and nothing had been built 6 years later. A further Rs 63 million budgeted from 2021-22 to 2023-24 was not spent.(1) Meanwhile, in 2024-25 Rs 36 million was paid as rent to 605 eligible beneficiaries.(1)

Payments to people on low incomes

The state also pays money directly to people who qualify. These payments are managed by the Social Security Division of the Ministry of Social Integration. In 2024-25 the division paid Rs 70.8 billion in pensions alone, to about 320,000 people.(1) The report looks at the smaller payments it calls social aid, and at what happens when they go to someone who should not get them.

An overpayment is money paid to someone who should have received less, or nothing. It happens when a person's situation changes and the division is not told in time: a new job or a marriage. Beneficiaries must report these changes, but the report says some are not aware of this duty or of what follows if they do not. The division also does not yet have data sharing in place with the tax authority, the MRA, and the MRA's own records are updated late.(1)

On 30 June 2025, Rs 14.5 million of overpaid social aid had still not been recovered. During 2024-25 only 27% of the money owed was recovered, and 88% of the older debts and 58% of the new ones were still unpaid.(1) In 2024-25 alone, Rs 4.5 million was overpaid in 301 new cases. Rs 1.8 million of it, in 119 cases, came from changes of job.(1)

Marriage is the other cause. The division runs a remarriage matching exercise to find beneficiaries who have married. In 2024-25 it found 15 new cases worth Rs 558,000, and had recovered only 9% of it.(1) The largest was a person who married in December 2018 and kept being paid until May 2024: 66 months and Rs 230,100 in all, about Rs 3,490 a month (our calculation).(1) The report does not say which benefit this was. For comparison, the Surviving Partner Allowance, introduced in 2014 for certain women whose partner has died, is only payable if the woman has not married since.(1)

A separate scheme targets poverty itself. The Marshall Plan Against Poverty, in place since 1 December 2016, aims to end absolute poverty. Its Empowerment Support Scheme pays a monthly subsistence allowance to households on the Social Register of Mauritius, after they sign a social contract with the National Empowerment Foundation. It also offers help with work, health, children's education and family life.(1) In 2024-25 it paid Rs 479.3 million to 8,761 households, with an income ceiling of Rs 14,650.(1)

The auditor asks whether it works. Over almost 9 years the scheme and its education support cost Rs 3.4 billion, and 2,853 households left poverty.(1) The contract was meant to last 2 to 3 years, yet 847 households, 12% of those eligible, stayed registered for nearly 9 years.(1) And who qualifies is decided by a Proxy Means Test, an estimate of a household's living standard from its housing, its members and its access to basic services. That test still rests on a household survey from 2012, although newer data has been available since March 2025. The report warns that some households may turn out not to be eligible once it is updated.(1)

Schools and tablets

Schools show the same gap between buying something and using it. The Early Digital Learning Programme began in 2018, with India's collaboration, to bring tablets and online teaching tools to government and private-aided primary schools. It covered 273 schools and Grades 1 to 6 by 2023, with the aim of letting pupils learn more independently.(1) India gave a grant of USD 14 million for the first two phases, matched by USD 8.4 million from Mauritius.(1)

The state bought 76,880 tablets at Rs 13,454 each, plus 2,950 projectors, 4,380 charging racks and 1,401 notebook computers. With maintenance, the programme had cost Rs 1.45 billion by July 2025.(1) For Grades 4 to 6 there is also an online platform, the Classroom Management System, where teachers manage lessons, track progress, share materials and set tests.(1)

Using it was another matter. In some of the 18 schools the auditors visited, pupils in the youngest grades had to share tablets, some tablets and charging racks were defective, and the 5-year maintenance contract for the first two phases ran out in January 2024.(1) In all 273 schools, Grade 4 pupils could not use the platform during 2025 because usernames and passwords were never given out or came very late.(1) In Grade 5, teachers in 272 of 273 schools did not log in, and in Grade 6, teachers in 270 schools did not, more than 98% of teachers in all.(1) The reasons given include lack of enforcement, little monitoring by school management and inspectors, and the time it takes to take tablets out of their racks.(1)

The auditor's verdict: the programme did not give value for the taxpayers' money. The Ministry never set up a way to track how much the tablets were used or what pupils learned, so the report cannot say whether learning improved.(1)

Separately, there are fewer children. Births fell from 20,205 in 2000 to 12,853 in 2024, and primary pupils from 123,562 in 2005 to 82,974 in 2025.(1) Riche en Eau Government School had just 11 pupils, and 20 more tablets than it needed.(1) And of the children who started Grade 1 in 2012, only 34.5% completed the Higher School Certificate.(1)

What it means for you

So how does all this reach a family? Take one finding at a time, and keep to what the report says.

The ambulance. Imagine a parent falls ill at home at 9 pm. At that hour one SAMU vehicle covers your whole region. If it is already on another case, the help that comes may be a routine ambulance or a police vehicle with no medical team on board, or you may have to take the patient yourself. In July 2025 that was the case for about 16 emergencies a day.(1) So call the SAMU at once and give a precise address.

Food and medicines. The report does not say that any meal made anyone ill because of fewer inspections, or that any medicine was faulty. It says the safety net is thinner than it should be: fewer visits to places that sell food, and no check on the 107 medicines already on sale. If you take regular medicines, do not stop because of this. If something worries you, ask your doctor or pharmacist.

Payments. If you receive a benefit and then start a job or marry, tell the Social Security Division at once. Otherwise the payments continue by mistake, and the division is expected to recover them later. In the 66-month case above, Rs 230,100 was overpaid, and the division is supposed to recover it.(1) And if you are in the poverty scheme, note that the test deciding who qualifies is based on 2012 data and may change.(1)

Schools and taxes. In some schools children in the early grades shared tablets or used defective ones, and in the upper grades the online platform was hardly used. The tablets cost Rs 13,454 each, and the programme Rs 1.45 billion in all, paid with taxes and part of an Indian grant.(1) The report cannot say how much children learned, because no formal tracking existed.

What parts 1 to 3 cover, and what is left

Together, the first three parts cover the public finances, social housing, water, the Triolet sports complex, police equipment, health, social aid and schools.(1)

That still leaves pesticides on vegetables, waste and beaches, drains and roads, other police and prison findings, the courts and the compensation the state paid after court cases. Part 4 covers them on 7 November.

The full brief on MoBriefs has the charts, what it means for you, and every source.

Open in MoBriefs Get the free app

Sources

  1. National Audit Office: Certificate of Audit and Report of the Director of Audit on the accounts of the Government, financial year 2024-25 (February 2026)

Related briefs

480 households came off poverty aid through work: what the new Rs 16,400 limit changes22 November 2026 · Between December 2024 and October 2026, 1,537 households stopped receiving the state's help for the poorest families, and 480 of them because a…Mauritian pupils are learning less. The world is too, but some countries found a way back11 November 2026 · School Certificate results are the lowest in at least ten years, and Mauritius's first PISA test since 2010 shows more than half of 15-year-olds…Mauritius leads Africa in a Commonwealth ranking on young people and AI. The real test is jobs10 November 2026 · A new index ranks Mauritius 8th of 56 Commonwealth countries, and first in Africa, for how well it prepares young people for artificial intelligence.…

Topics

Public finances and debt in MauritiusJobs, poverty and schools in MauritiusAll briefs

Lire en français